Web Exclusive: Cartridge Heater Selection Guidelines
by Eli Whitney, Dalton Electric Heating Co. Inc.
October 1, 2007
In this online-only sidebar to "Cartridge Heater
Considerations," the author offers tips for factoring in the cost of
heating when selecting cartridge heaters.
When it comes to selecting a cartridge heater, the cost is almost as
important as other considerations such as how it will perform in certain
processes and environment. And, it can be a tricky factor to determine because
the price of the heater vs. the cost of heating in an application can vary
wildly.
The purchase price of a particular cartridge heater may be much more
attractive than another, but the purchaser may have no idea what the
maintenance manager is going through. And the buyer may not understand how much
more he is paying for the use of the wrong heater.
Effective heat transfer will drop operating costs to heat a manufacturing
operation. If one heater price is three-quarters of another, but the other
lasts twice as long, it will improve operating life costs substantially. Longer
life translates to decreased maintenance costs and machine downtime. Heater
change-out costs can far exceed the initial cost of the cartridge.
If a cartridge heater seizes in a bore, the tool, platen or die must be
pulled and sent to the machine shop, generally to drill out the heater, a
time-consuming and expensive procedure. If a split-sheath cartridge heater is
used, this problem will be eliminated, or if a conventional heater is sized
properly, this concern can generally be avoided.
To maximize on the cost of heating, the effective purchaser of cartridge
heaters must be aware of the quality of a heater, its use and life in an
application, and the ramifications of failure on replacement and maintenance.
|