Clearly, the advantages of SCR power controls outweigh the disadvantages. The biggest advantages are high reliability and low maintenance requirements. Because the SCR is a solid-state device, there are no moving parts to wear out. Simply keeping it clean and cool provides users with many years of reliable service. Another advantage is control options. Compared with an on/off electromechanical contactor, an SCR provides fast response and high resolution as well as the ability to limit current and regulate load voltage, current or power. Disadvantages to using an SCR control can include low power factor, high harmonic currents and radio frequency interference (RFI) when using phase-fired power controllers.
To fully understand how an SCR power controller operates, it is important to understand how a silicon-controlled rectifier (SCR) works. The SCR is the power-handling electronic device in an SCR power control. Because an SCR conducts current in only one direction, two SCRs are connected in an inverse parallel, or "back-to-back," configuration when used as the power control (figure 1).
When power is applied to the line side of the SCR, a timed pulse is applied alternately to the gates of SCR 1 and 2. When SCR 1 is gated on, it conducts the positive half-cycle of the AC power; alternately, when SCR 2 is gated on, it conducts the negative half-cycle. The SCR pair commonly is called an AC switch.
Control Modes. There are three basic control modes: on/off, zero-firing and phase-firing. On/off control is the simplest method -- it merely duplicates the action of an electromechanical contactor. When a command signal is applied, the control turns on and conducts current. When the command signal is removed, the control turns off.
Zero-firing control switches the SCRs on and off -- much like on/off control -- but this method incorporates proportional control. With this control mode, the number of "on" or "off" AC cycles is varied to maintain as steady a voltage to the load as possible while turning the power on and off. Figure 2 shows the on and off AC cycles associated with a zero-fired SCR power control.
While effective, zero-firing is not suited for every application. Because zero-firing turns the SCR either completely on or off, the voltage applied to the load is either zero or full. This is not acceptable with an exotic load element such as molybdenum disilicide. Molybdenum disilicide's resistance is nearly zero when cold, but it increases with temperature. Ohm's law shows that if zero-firing was used to control a molybdenum disilicide load element, large current surges would result each time the SCR was turned on when the element was cold. These current surges can damage SCRs and cause nuisance fuse blowing. This application would be better suited to phase-firing.
Phase-firing provides infinitely variable control of voltage to the load -- much like a light dimmer. Similar to zero-firing, with phase-firing, timed gate pulses are fed to the SCRs. But, with this control mode, each of the two SCRs in an AC switch is turned on only for a portion of the half-cycle it is controlling (figure 3).
If the load resistance change is small, a zero-fired controller is the right choice. By contrast, if the load resistance change is large -- as with molybdenum disilicide or silicon carbide element -- a phase-fired SCR power controller is the correct choice.
Inductive loads such as a transformer-coupled load can cause high in-rush currents when used with zero-firing. In this case, using a phase-fired controller allows the load voltage to ramp up and avoids large current surges.
When selecting an SCR power controller, take the following steps:
- Determine the type of load element and whether on/off, zero or phase-firing is required.
- Determine the line voltage and the number of phases to be controlled.
- If the load is three-phase, determine whether it is three-or four-wire connected.
- Calculate the maximum load current required at full output voltage, regardless of the desired load voltage. (SCRs can turn full-on when not expected or, if the SCR fails shorted, full-line voltage would be applied to the load.)
Phase-firing can be used with nearly any load type; on/off and zero-fired control should only be used with resistive loads.
One caution: The lower power factor, higher harmonic currents and radio frequency interference generated by the high rising waveforms associated with phase-firing can be a problem. Using zero-firing, if the load type allows, can eliminate these problems.
Most electrical heat control devices do not offer the flexibility available with SCR power controls. Its flexibility, ease of application and reliability account for its popularity.